S.C. State’s Harry Carson: ‘Captain for Life’

Harry Carson has a pretty good memory, especially for a 72-year-old who spent a large portion of his life slamming, often head-first, into opposing football players. The Florence native doesn’t take that memory for granted.

He knows, only too well, it could’ve been much different. And still might be.

On Sept. 18, officials in Carson’s hometown announced its Freedom Florence Recreation Center football complex will be named in his honor, honoring him and three other native sons. It’d be hard to find a more worthy recipient.

A standout for Florence’s Wilson and McClenaghan high school teams, he went on to earn All-Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference honors at South Carolina State, then played 13 seasons at linebacker with the NFL’s New York Giants, where he was a nine-time Pro Bowl selection and a Super Bowl XXI champion. Added to all of that is his inductions into the College and Pro Football Halls of Fame in 2002 and 2006, respectively.

Carson remembers it all, and more. Much more, starting with how it could’ve ended before it began.

“One of the things I think very heavily about is when I lived at 404 John Street” as a youngster, he said from his home in Franklin Lakes, NJ. “In October, there was a fire in my house, and when the firemen got there, I was still in bed – I was a very sound sleeper.

“I think about, if that fireman hadn’t grabbed me and thrown me out the window to his partner, where would I be? My brother sustained severe burns. I came through without any adverse injury.”

There were other adversities, though. His career almost ended before it began when, in a dispute with his coach, he quit the Wilson High team — instead, he played on a Boys Club team run by E.J. McIver and eventually rejoined the high school team.

“I had a pain in my gut about quitting, but I went back and made the team,” he said.

Harry Carson during his South Carolina State days in Orangeburg, S.C. Above: Carson (53), seen here in Super Bowl XXI, played linebacker for 13 seasons for the NFL’s New York Giants, 10 of those as the team’s captain. In 2006, he was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. (courtesy of the New York Giants)

Another dispute with a different coach at McClenaghan led Carson to quit again. This time, a teacher, Dorothy Jo McDuffie, took him to visit S.C. State, her alma mater, where he met future teammate Donnie Shell, and in 1973 the Bulldogs’ new coach, Willie Jeffries.

“The best thing that ever happened to me,” Carson said. “I played for an institution that took care of me. In four years, I never missed a game.”

With the Giants, he switched from defensive lineman to bruising middle linebacker. “I was probably the third African-American to play a position (then) reserved for whites,” he said. “(The late coach) Marty Schottenheimer saw something in me I didn’t see in myself, and I was able to establish myself as one of the best at the position.”

On a team with another future Hall of Famer, Lawrence Taylor, Carson served as the Giants’ captain for 10 seasons. In 2011, he wrote his autobiography, “Captain for Life,” a title he still considers his.

Two moments established Carson in that “life” role.

In 2004, after being passed over for the Pro Football Hall of Fame several times, he made the unprecedented decision to write the Hall of Fame and declare himself no longer a willing candidate. Two years later, the Hall of Fame overruled his objections and inducted him into its ranks.

But perhaps nothing confirmed his stature more than when, during his 2006 Hall of Fame induction, he spoke out about his and other players’ issues with concussions. He’d seen a number of older retired players dealing with depression, dementia, Alzheimer’s disease and Lou Gehrig’s disease brought on by undiagnosed brain trauma. Some players died early or committed suicide, with hundreds diagnosed after their deaths with chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE).

“Most players felt shafted by the NFL,” Carson told the Hall of Fame audience, a contention he repeated in a 2013 interview on PBS’s “Frontline” series. “The league had to do a much better job of taking care of its own.” In 2011, more than 2,000 former players dealing with CTE and other neurological concerns had joined in a lawsuit against the NFL. Ultimately, the league set aside a fund of $764 million for former players — as of this year, payable monetary amounts had reached $1.73 billion.

Carson in his interview with Frontline’s Michael Kirk told of dealing with depression and his own thoughts of suicide. Once in 1981, he said, he nearly decided to drive off the Tappan Zee Bridge. “I was depressed but didn’t know why,” he said in 2013.

Harry Carson, who starred at S.C. State before going on to a Hall of Fame career with the NFL’s New York Giants, is seen here during a recent visit to his hometown of Florence, S.C. (courtesy of ABC Florence)

Today, Carson, who has spoken slowly and deliberately in interviews dating to 2004, said he still deals with issues he knows arose from football. “I’m doing relatively well,” he said. “I’m very patient with myself. I still say I’m not 100 percent.”

He suspects he might have CTE, which can only be determined after death. He was diagnosed with post-concussion syndrome in 1990, and says his neurological specialist told him “you have to learn how to manage it.”

 “I’ve managed very well,” he said. “I don’t know what’s down the pike, but it’s better to know (his situation). People don’t want to talk about it, but it’s real. Some guys when their careers are over, they wind up wanting to shoot someone, feel like they’re going crazy.”

Carson considers himself to be lucky so far. “I know when things are good and not so good,” he said. “The most important thing is to enjoy my life.” He has a constant companion in his dog Charlie, who “wants to go wherever I go.” When asked for his autograph now, he gives it away … but suggests a donation to one of several New Jersey-area charities, including a food bank and aid for the homeless.

 His sons are a doctor (Donald) and an urban planner (Lucky) — daughter Aja is a hospital administrator. He and his wife, Maribel, a Panama native, are considering moving there to escape New Jersey winters. “I’m living my best life. I’m comfortable where I am in life,” Carson said.

He’s equally comfortable talking about a topic that, he said, went unexamined for too long. “If someone wants me to speak about football and injuries, I’m more than willing to share my experiences.” Afterwards, “some will come up to me and whisper, ‘Thanks for saying what you say about concussions.’ I’ve been armed with information a lot of people don’t know.”

Carson knows this: his 4-year-old grandson Lenny (one of five grandkids ranging in age from 21 to 2) will not play football if “Pop Pop” has anything to say. “If I knew (growing up) what I know now …” he said, letting the end of that statement hang in the air.

“I wasn’t born to be a football player,” he said. “I fell into it, sometimes for all the wrong reasons. (But) I played the game and left it knowing I gave my all. I got my (college) degree before I stepped on an NFL field. And I know people respect me for the way I played the game.”

Respect means being a “captain for life.” Respect means your hometown honoring you … if attaching your name to a football facility sends a mixed message.

“The mayor (of Florence) asked me if would do the city an honor by allowing them to recognize me,” he said. “I thought she was joking at first.” For the dedication ceremony later this month or in November, Carson will fly back to where it all began for him.

That brings up another long-ago memory of growing up in Florence. “There was a park in east Florence, that’s where we used to go,” he said. “There was a sprinkler system for people to cool off in summer, a baseball field. I lived 4-5 blocks away — that’s where I played with friends.”

He chuckled then. “So we’ve come a long way,” he said. Harry Carson’s memories remain vivid, memories football’s ravages couldn’t erase.

Harry Carson wearing his Pro Football Hall of Fame Gold Jacket. (courtesy of the New York Giants)
Scroll to Top